“Make America Great Again” has been
a Trump motto even during his first run for the presidency in 2015.
It's not new (Reagan used it, for instance), but it does bring up a
question: when was America great, according to Trump? Where does his
backward look land in history? If you ask MAGA believers, you get
many different answers and views on this.
Trump himself has helpfully answered
this at least to a degree. Trump told the New York Times when asked
when America's power was greatest: "No if you really look at it,
it was the turn of the century, that’s when we were a
great, when we were really starting to go robust. But if you
look back, it really was, there was a period of time when we were
developing at the turn of the century which was a pretty wild time
for this country and pretty wild in terms of building that machine,
that machine was really based on entrepreneurship etc, etc.” At a
rally in Phoenix, Trump said “President McKinley made our country
very rich through tariffs and through talent. He was a natural
businessman. “ (also) “He was a strong believer in tariffs, and
we were actually probably wealthiest of any time, relatively
speaking, at any point in the history of our country.“ McKinley
was president from 1896 until 1901, when he was killed by an
assassin.
1901 was within what is called The
Gilded Age, which was a time when extremely wealthy men known as
robber barons owned most all of the commercial activity of the
country. They essentially ran monopolies of steel, sugar, rails, and
other essential products. JP Morgan almost single-handedly ran the
financial activities of the country, so much so that he was actually
called upon to bail out the US government in 1893. The Gilded Age
was thus controlled by what we today call oligarchs: “...the high
water mark of US wealth concentration and inequality occurred during
the quarter-century before World War 1... a somewhat informed guess
would put the zenith around 1901 or 1902” [Wealth and Democracy, by
Kevin Phillips, p. 122]. The average American at this time was
barely scraping by, but the super rich like Trump today were powerful
and essentially untouchable.
Many of these robber barons subscribed
to Social Darwinism, which teaches that the Survival of the Fittest
applies to the business world as well. The rich are rich, the theory
goes, because they are the “fittest” within the economy. The
poor are unfit and thus are rightfully in their lower condition. A
biographer of Andrew Carnegie noted that to him, “If his friends,
subordinates, and competition suffered in this battle for survival,
such was evolution. There was no room for sympathy...” [Carnegie,
by Peter Krass, p. 154].
Immigration to the United States was in
full swing in 1901. There was backlash, however, where some groups
were considered unable to fit in to United States culture. Chinese,
for example, were forbidden entry. Black Americans were still
considered inferior. Jim Crow laws enforced segregation and
prevented blacks from voting. Prejudice was a strong aspect of
1901.
Manufacturing jobs were big in 1901.
10 hour days, 6 days a week were typical requirements. There was no
worker's compensation. Child labor was common. The average annual
income was $500 (about $19,000 in today's dollars). But “by the
beginning of the 20th century, gross domestic product and industrial
production in the United States led the world. “
[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gilded_Age]
1901 was a year of technological
growth, after the telephone but before motion pictures. It was the
beginning of radio. The Olds automobile came on the market, but it
was only a 3hp, one-cylinder vehicle. Steam engines powered ships to
and from the old world, making transport much faster.
There was no income tax in 1901, as
most federal government income was from tariffs. The New York stock
market had its first crash this year.
The United States was in a period of
territorial capture. Hawaii, Panama, the Philippines, Cuba, and
Puerto Rico came under US control during McKinley's presidency.
So this is when Donald Trump thinks
America should look back on with longing. If we could just emulate
some aspects of the Gilded Age, America could be great again. But
really, what was so great about that time? Through Trump's eyes, we
quickly see the oligarchs of the time and the great control they had
over the country. This would be quite appealing to Trump, though not
to the rest of us. Through Trump's eyes, restricting the “other" -
be that blacks, foreigners, the poor - would also induce a yearning
for a time when those Not Like Us could be controlled or even
expelled. Through Trump's eyes, capturing new territory looks quite
beneficial to the bottom line, no matter the messiness of trying to
turn the unwilling into subjects. Can the federal government run off
income from tariffs? It did in 1901, so why not now?
So yes, it's quite understandable that
1901 has an attraction to Trump. But not so much to the rest of us.
But right now we're living in Trump's world, so we have the oligarchs
taking power, an aggressive attack on foreigners (even ones here
legally), a revival of Empire Building, and a push to replace income
tax with tariffs. With all this going on, it's easy to see that Trump
does indeed look to 1901 for inspiration, and to Make America Great
Again.